CBC leaves Twitter after being labeled as ‘government-funded media’

The tag has been criticized by news outlets for unfairly undermining their credibility.

Updated at 3:27 p.m. on April 17

CBC paused activities on Twitter after it had a tag classifying it as “government-funded media” added to its account, following a week where several other news outlets decried the classification for undermining their credibility and independence.

As of Monday morning, the tag only appeared on the main @CBC account. It has not yet been applied to @CBCNews, @CBCRadioCanada, breaking news account @CBCAlerts or accounts for CBC’s local markets.

In a statement that was also posted to Twitter on Sunday evening, CBC pointed to Twitter’s own definition of government-funded media, classified as news outlets where the government “may have varying degrees of government involvement over editorial content.”

CBC said there are several reasons why this isn’t true in its case. Firstly, CBC’s editorial independence is protected in law in the Broadcasting Act. Further, its funding is voted on and passed by all members of parliament. In addition, CBC pointed to its own Journalistic Standards and Practices, as well as its independent ombudsman, as internal controls in place to ensure editorial independence.

At the time, CBC had not said whether not it would suspend activities on the platform, as other news outlets labeled as “government-funded media” in the last week have. However, on Monday afternoon, a tweet from the @CBCRadioCanada account said it would go on pause.

“Our journalism is impartial and independent,” the tweet read. “To suggest otherwise is untrue. That is why we are pausing our activities on Twitter.”

Last week, U.S. public radio outlet NPR stated it would no longer be posting on Twitter after it had a “government-funded media” tag added to its profile. While NPR and similar outlets do receive government funds through grants and other sources, NPR expressed concern that the tag implied government control over its coverage, and undermined its credibility as an independent news source. A number of other public outlets in the U.S. have since followed suit after receiving the tag themselves, citing similar concerns.

In the U.K., the BBC also briefly had “government-funded media” added to its profile, though it was changed to “publicly funded media” after the broadcaster objected to the classification.

Following the NPR situation, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre asked Twitter to add the label to CBC’s account, saying in a letter that it was necessary to protect Canadians from “disinformation and manipulation by state media.” After the tag was added, Poilievre tweeted that the CBC had been “officially exposed as ‘government-funded media.'”

CBC received more than $1.2 billion in government funding in 2021-2022, according to its annual report, down from roughly $1.4 billion the prior year.

A push to “defund the CBC” has been a major talking point for Poilievre this year, saying the national broadcaster undermines other media outlets, as well as being “Trudeau propaganda.”

Tags:


,